1. AI as a Strategic Thinking Partner
Claude has read thousands of business books, case studies, academic papers, and strategic frameworks. It understands Porter's Five Forces, Blue Ocean Strategy, Jobs to be Done, OKRs, SWOT, competitive positioning, and much more.
But here's the key: Claude is not a strategist. It's a thinking partner. Its job is to pressure-test your ideas, reflect your assumptions back at you, and help you see what you're missing.
The best executives "think out loud" with Claude. They don't ask for answers. They ask questions:
- "What am I not thinking about?"
- "What assumptions am I making that might be wrong?"
- "What does the opposite case look like?"
- "If this decision goes wrong in 1 year, what happened?"
- "Who disagrees with me, and why?"
- "What would a competitor do here?"
ℹ️
Golden Rule: Claude will reflect your assumptions back at you. If you walk into it saying "We should pivot to AI," Claude might say "Okay, let's test that assumption." It's your job to actually do the testing. Claude is a sounding board, not an oracle.
2. Decision Frameworks
Use Claude with proven decision frameworks to structure your thinking and catch blind spots.
Framework 1: Pros/Cons with Weighted Importance
Not just a list of pros and cons, but weighted by importance and likelihood. This forces you to distinguish between "nice to have" and "deal-breaker."
I'm deciding whether to {decision}.
My current thinking: {brief summary of your position}
List the pros and cons. For each, rate:
1. Impact (1-5, where 5 is game-changing)
2. Likelihood (1-5, where 5 is certain)
3. Reversibility (can we undo this decision later?)
After listing, tell me: What's the weighted score for doing this vs. not doing it? Which factor should I worry about most?
Framework 2: Pre-Mortem
Imagine your decision failed spectacularly in 1 year. What went wrong? This uncovers hidden risks you haven't thought about.
Assume I made the decision to {decision} and it completely failed in 1 year.
Walk me through: What happened? What went wrong? What did I not anticipate?
Then, for each failure mode you identify, suggest: What could I do now to prevent it?
Framework 3: Second-Order Thinking
Most people think about what happens directly from their decision. Second-order thinking asks: what happens as a result of that? Third-order?
I'm thinking about {decision}.
Walk me through the second and third-order consequences:
1. What's the direct result of this decision?
2. What happens as a result of that? (How do customers react? How do competitors respond?)
3. What happens as a result of that? (How does the market shift? How do other stakeholders respond?)
Which consequence is most risky?
Framework 4: Devil's Advocate
You're convinced the decision is right. Claude plays the other side—hard—so you can stress-test your thinking.
I want to {decision}. Here's why I think it's right: {your reasoning}.
Play devil's advocate. Argue STRONGLY against this decision. What am I overlooking? Why might this fail? What's the case for the opposite?
Don't be nice—make me defend my position.
💡
Best Practice: Don't make big decisions in one conversation. Use multiple frameworks. If the same concerns come up in pre-mortem, devil's advocate, and second-order thinking, those are probably real risks.
Learn more about decision frameworks: Farnam Street decision-making guide
3. SWOT, Scenario Planning, and Competitive Analysis
These are strategic tools that are even more powerful with Claude. Use the prompts below to do real analysis.
SWOT Analysis
Run a SWOT analysis for {our company/product/initiative}.
Context:
- Who are we? {brief description}
- What's the market? {brief description}
- What's our goal? {what are we trying to achieve?}
Generate:
1. Strengths: What do we do better than competitors?
2. Weaknesses: What are we bad at? Where are we vulnerable?
3. Opportunities: What trends or gaps can we exploit?
4. Threats: What could go wrong? Who could outcompete us?
Format as a 2x2 grid and prioritize the top 3 in each quadrant.
Strengths (Positive Internal)
What we're good at. Our edge.
Opportunities (Positive External)
Market gaps. Trends we can ride.
Weaknesses (Negative Internal)
What we're bad at. Our blind spots.
Threats (Negative External)
Competition. Disruption. Market shifts.
Scenario Planning
Best case, worst case, most likely. This helps you prepare for what might happen.
Create three scenarios for {market/company/product} over the next 2-3 years.
Context: {your current situation and assumptions}
Scenario 1 - Best Case: Everything goes right. What would it look like? How would we win?
Scenario 2 - Worst Case: Everything goes wrong. What went wrong? How does the market look?
Scenario 3 - Most Likely: Somewhere in the middle. What's the realistic outcome?
For each scenario, tell me: What's our strategy? What should we do now to prepare?
Competitive Analysis
Analyze the competitive landscape for {our product/service}.
Our position:
- What do we offer? {description}
- Who are our customers? {target market}
- What's our price point? {pricing}
- What's our unique advantage? {your differentiation}
Competitors: {list 2-3 key competitors}
For each competitor, analyze:
1. What do they do well?
2. Where are they vulnerable?
3. How would they respond to our moves?
Then tell me: What's our best competitive position? What should we avoid?
⚠️
Reality Check: These analyses are only as good as the information you provide. If you say "we have no weaknesses," Claude will call that out. Be honest about your situation.
4. Strategy for Your Profession
Strategic thinking looks different depending on your role. Here are profession-specific use cases:
Manager
I need to plan resources for {quarter/project}.
Team size: {headcount and roles}
Projects: {list your priorities}
Constraints: {hiring freeze? Attrition? Time pressure?}
Should we build in-house or outsource? Where are we overextended? Where do we have slack?
Manager
Assess the risks for {project}.
Scope: {what are we building/doing?}
Timeline: {by when?}
Budget: {resources available}
Team: {who's involved?}
What could derail us? What's the critical path? Where should we add buffer?
Business Owner
We're considering entering {new market/segment/geography}.
Current position: {our business today}
Opportunity: {market size, growth, margins}
Barriers: {capital, expertise, competition, regulations}
Should we do this? What would success look like? What's the minimal viable entry?
Business Owner
Help me think through pricing for {product/service}.
Value: {what problem does this solve? Why should they pay?}
Customers: {who are they? What's their budget?}
Competitors: {what do they charge?}
Cost: {what's our cost to deliver?}
What pricing model makes sense? (Subscription, one-time, usage-based, freemium?) What's the right price point?
Doctor/Healthcare
I'm evaluating treatment options for {condition}.
Patient: {demographics, comorbidities, preferences}
Options: {list treatment approaches}
Evidence: {what does research show?}
Constraints: {insurance, access, patient tolerance}
What's the best pathway? What are the decision points? What could go wrong?
Teacher
I'm designing {course/unit}.
Learning objectives: {what should students know?}
Students: {age, background, challenges}
Constraints: {time, resources, standards}
Assessment: {how will we measure learning?}
What's the best sequence of topics? Where do students usually struggle? How do we make it relevant?
Lawyer
I'm evaluating strategy for {case}.
Facts: {what happened?}
Legal issues: {what laws apply?}
Risks: {what could we lose?}
Opportunities: {what could we win?}
Resources: {time, budget, team}
What's our best strategy? Should we settle or litigate? What's the critical issue?
Analyst
I've analyzed {market/segment} and found: {key findings}.
What does this mean for our strategy? Should we invest more, invest less, or pivot? Who should know about this?
🖥️HANDS-ON EXERCISE⏱ 25 min
Hands-On: Make a Real Decision
In 25 minutes, use Claude to think through an actual decision you're facing at work.
- Step 1: Pick a real decision you're currently facing (hire someone, launch a feature, enter a market, change a process, anything)
- Step 2: Run the Pre-Mortem analysis: "Assume this fails in 1 year. What went wrong?"
- Step 3: Run the Devil's Advocate analysis: "Argue strongly against this decision"
- Step 4: Ask Claude: "What am I not considering? What assumptions am I making?"
- Step 5: Write a one-sentence decision statement: "{Decision}: Yes/No. Why."
- Step 6: Identify the riskiest assumption and how you'll test it
Template 1: Pre-Mortem Prompt
Start here to uncover hidden risks:
Imagine I {made this decision} and it completely failed in 1 year.
Walk me through: What happened? What did I not anticipate? What warning signs should I have seen?
Then tell me: What can I do RIGHT NOW to reduce these risks?
Template 2: Devil's Advocate Prompt
Get the opposing view:
I want to {make this decision}. I think it's right because: {your reasoning}.
Be a strong devil's advocate. Argue against this decision. What's the case for doing the opposite? Where am I vulnerable?
Quick Reference: Strategic Thinking Prompts
Pre-MortemAssume failure. Walk backward from 1 year out. What went wrong? What are the hidden risks?
Second-Order ThinkingDon't just think about direct consequences. What happens as a result of that result?
SWOT AnalysisStrengths (what we do well), Weaknesses (what we suck at), Opportunities (what we can exploit), Threats (what could beat us)
Devil's AdvocateStrong argument against your position. Why might the opposite be true? Where could you be wrong?
Scenario PlanningBest case / Most likely / Worst case. What does each look like? What's our strategy in each?
Critical QuestionAsk Claude: "What am I not thinking about?" Let it surface blind spots you're missing.